My top 15 would probably look like this:

15. I'd Die For You
14. Satellite
13. Keep the Faith
12. I Will Drive You Home
11. Superman Tonight
10. Without Love
09. Something to Believe in
08. Bells of Freedom
07. Silent Night
06. These Days
05. Bed of Roses
04. Welcome to Wherever You Are
03. These Open Arms
02. Dry County
01. Livin' on a Prayer

And my bottom 15 would probably look like this (with comments explaining why I hate each of these songs):
15. Seat Next to You (extremely boring, ruined by female vocals)
14. I Get a Rush (see comment on Taking it Back)
13. Complicated (basically a teen pop / disney song sung by an old man instead of a young girl)
12. Taking it Back (don't know why I hate this one, I just do)
11. Color Me In (extremely boring)
10. King of the Mountain (way too cheesy)
09. Fear (by far the worst BJ song from the '90s)
08. Captain Crash & the Beauty Queen From Mars (boring and overplayed)
07. God Bless This Mess (basically a carbon copy of THINFS, should not have been on the album. Goodnight NY should've been in its place)
06. Ain't No Cure for Love (totally boring and uninteresting)
05. Last Cigarette (some of the most disgusting lyrics in any BJ song)
04. We Got it Going on (stop f***ing playing this song at every g*****n show! The lyrics are terrible!)
03. I Love This Town (annoying and overplayed. Studio version is OK I guess)
02. Social Disease (wtf is that stupid intro!?)
01. Bad Medicine (just f*** awful in my opinion, especially live)