So, problem solved...
For some reason when I put the CD in my PS3, it was only playing 12 tracks. But I got out my old CD player and sure enough...15 tracks. Very weird. I've never had a problem playing Japanese CDs in my PS3 before. It just...makes no sense. Consider me really confused on this one.
Well at least I got it playing now. I know I'm in the minority, but I love TLFR. Every song.