Quote:
Originally Posted by semigoodlooking
Perhaps unsurprisingly, Slippery, New Jersey, Keep the Faith, and These Days. Although, I did spend some years lying to myself about the quality of the rest of the catalog, trying to be the "good fan".
|
Before I would say it's similar for me, but now I think differently. All those albums are very much flawed. My personal favourite (KTF) is basically trash in about half of its' length. TD that has mythological status in fanbase is very hit and miss. SWW as the best selling of this band and one of the best selling albums of all time in pop culture is combination of stadium hit singles and subpar hair metal fillers.
What I think makes a difference between golden years (1986-1995) and following output is mostly the perspective that Jovi was, first, THE pop/rock band of the times, and then, the international live iconic band with chip on the shoulder. Or even more bluntly, in the 80's, Jovi in the US was something like Bieber or Taylor Swift today. Similar to international scene in the 90's, regardless of grunge movement.
But later, Jovi was just another stadium band, with no real relevance on the radio and in charts, with few exceptions. I was introduced to band in 2005, but still I romanticized the legacy years, not only as legacy of the band, but also of rock music. But in this process, I did find myself overvaluating those early albums for wrong reasons.
For example, I do rate TD rather significantly better than 2020, but not primarily due to quality of songwriting or even producing (Shanks' best work IMO is 2020), but effort and possibilities of Jon's voice mostly. With 90's voice, Blood in the Water is perhaps better than anything on TD.
Just my two cents, I don't think anybody is wrong, just trying to rationalize all our perspectives. Still, even though HAND introduced me to the band, I don't see it as great album, but mostly cause fanbase don't see it. Quite frankly, there's no "perfect" Jovi album, just its meaning with context and live tour that then transcends the time and objective quality.